skip to main | skip to sidebar
Global Labour Column Archive
  • HOME
    • ABOUT US
    • GLC ANTHOLOGIES
  • LINKS
    • RECOMMENDED SITES
    • DISCLAIMER
  • AUTHORS
  • GLOBAL BOARD
  • CONTACT
  • GLU
  • ICDD
  • Follow Us on Twitter
  • Monday, February 6, 2012

    Minimum Wages in Europe: a Strategy against Wage-Dumping Policies?

    Lars Vande Keybus
    In numerous countries such as Ireland, Greece, Portugal, Hungary, and others, the European Commission (EC) - in cooperation with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and European Central Bank (ECB) - has imposed a dramatic policy mix that consists of blind austerity, privatisation and wage cuts. Following the adoption of the notorious ‘six-pack’ in December 2011, it is clear that such policies will become a general rule all over Europe. The ‘six-pack’ sets up a structure in which the EC is granted a role as budgetary supervisor and punisher. The commission has the opportunity to almost automatically punish European Union (EU) members who do not follow recommendations to correct ‘excessive budgetary deficits’. The recommendations can range from adjustments in public sector pay, pension systems, indexation systems, unemployment benefits or privatisation schemes. Furthermore the ‘six-pack’ creates a new system of ‘macro-economic surveillance’. On the basis of a scoreboard consisting of a set of ten indicators covering the major sources of macro-economic imbalances, the EC can decide whether a member state suffers from an excessive imbalance. The commission can then provide recommendations and, if these are not thoroughly followed, it can prescribe sanctions. This strategy will ultimately lead to wage devaluation. In the absence of the possibility to devalue currencies, the EC is pushing for a strategy to devalue wages. This strategy is wrong and foolish for several economic and social reasons. But I would like to focus on the strategies to counter this policy.
    In the coming years it is clear that wage-setting will be executed at a European level. Therefore the European trade union movement needs to develop a Europe-wide offensive to protect wages. Along with coordinating collective bargaining, minimum wages play an essential part in countering the Europe-wide attack on wages. I would like to elaborate on the possibility of a Europe-wide minimum wage.
    In Europe there are several systems of minimum wages. Some countries have a statutory national minimum wage as a universal wage floor - set by the government, or set by an agreement between employers’ organisations and trade unions - while others only have sectoral or occupational minimum wages with no universal wage floor. In Belgium employers’ organisations and trade unions have agreed on a statutory national minimum wage, but on a sectoral or occupational level higher minimum wages can be agreed.
    I strongly believe that minimum wages, covering all workers - including those who are not covered by collective bargaining - are an essential part of cross-sectoral solidarity. In Belgium this has proven to be one of the main methods of preventing inequality from rising in the past 25 years. A recent Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) publication “Divided We Stand: Why inequality keeps rising” (December 2011) demonstrates that in the period 1985-2008 income inequality increased in both high- and low-inequality countries, despite the employment growth in these countries. Belgium was one of the best performing countries. However, in countries that usually obtain high scores in such international comparisons (such as Sweden, Norway, Denmark or Finland) inequality has increased dramatically (see graph below). Inequality was one of the main drivers behind the current economic crisis, without any doubt it should be the focal point of European politics in the years to come.

    Gini coefficients of income inequality, 1985 – 2008
    Source: OECD, 2011
    Therefore I must plead for a universal system of European minimum wage floors. This system would respect the national traditions of social dialogue, using law and/or collective agreements, but would cover, whatever the tool, all workers. It would define a minimum wage in relative, not in absolute terms, e.g. a percentage of the median or average wage level. In 2009, 8.4% of the people at work in the EU were below the ‘at-risk-of-poverty’ threshold. 14% of the working people in the EU earned less than 60% of the mean wage. Almost one fifth of those who earn less than 60% of the mean wage were at risk of poverty. When setting the standards it is imperative to find a principle that defines the minimum wage in such a way that it provides a decent wage for everyone and diminishes the percentage of the working poor. In Europe the minimum wage ranges from 30% to 50% of the average monthly earnings (Eurostat), in most cases below the poverty line. This percentage even declined in a number of countries during recent years. Therefore we believe that as a principle (determined by law or national collective agreement) minimum wages should be at least 60% of the relevant national (or sectoral) average wage.
    Countries with a high union density and collective bargaining coverage (e.g. Scandinavian countries) are reluctant to support the concept of a universal European wage floor. They believe it forms a threat to their collective bargaining power and their impact as a trade union. This fear is reasonable, but exaggerated. Countries such as Belgium, France, Spain and the Netherlands prove that a national minimum wage (determined by law or a national collective agreement) can be complementary to high collective bargaining coverage. A national minimum wage leads to an increased social legitimacy of trade unions. It is the ultimate proof that they do not only protect those who are covered by collective bargaining, but also those who – unfortunately – do not fall under collective agreements. As trade unions it is our moral duty to protect everyone in society, everyone who cannot or is not permitted to organise themselves.
    In times where trade unions plead for more solidarity within the EU, a system of European minimum wages is the way to create solidarity among workers. Minimum wages are not an objective in themselves. They are only an instrument to fight rising inequalities and increased precarious work. The European trade union movement should find a rapid agreement on the principles and standards for a system of European minimum wages. These principles must define, in our view, the standards for national minimum wages, determined either by law or a national collective agreement.

    Download this article as pdf

    Lars Vande Keybus is an economic advisor at the Belgian trade union ABVV-FGTB. His specialties include macro-economic policy, European Economic Governance, Trade & Globalisation and Decent Work campaigning.

    Posted in: Europe,Inequality,Trade Unions,Wage
    Email This BlogThis! Share to X Share to Facebook
    Newer Post Older Post Home

    0 Comments:

    Post a Comment

    Share

    Twitter Facebook Stumbleupon Favorites More

    Subscribe to the Mailing List

    If you want to subscribe to the GLC mailing list, please click here or send an empty email to "List-GLColumn-subscribe@global-labour-university.org"

    Contribute to the GLC

    If you want to contribute to the Global Labour Column, please read here the Guidelines for Contributions

    Languages






    Donations

    More Info

    Popular Posts

      T-Shirt Economics: Labour in the Imperialist World Economy
      Chinese Construction Companies in Africa: A Challenge for Trade Unions
      Ruskin, the trade union college, is under siege

    TAGS

    Trade Unions Financial Crisis Workers' rights Globalisation Neoliberalism Labour Market Collective Bargaining Decent Work Inequality Labour Standards Wage Social Movements Europe Development Strategies Struggle Progressive alliances Strike Growth Labour Labour rights Financial Market Tax Financial Regulation Social Security Public Investment Social Democracy South Africa Economic Democracy Fiscal Space Germany Informal Economy Corporate Governance Freedom of Association ILO Minimum Wage United States Competitiveness Human Rights Labour Movements Trade Union Austerity Central Bank Environment Free Trade Free Trade Agreement Greece Labour Movement Social Protection State Funding Transnational Solidarity Unemployment Vietnam Workers’ Rights Crowd Work Domestic Workers Economic Crisis Education Employment Forced Labour France Global Warming Labour Market Flexibility Labour Statistics Migration National Minimum Wage Public Works Programmes Trade Union Divisions Workers' unity Agriculture Brexit Care Work Construction Sector Cooperatives Crisis Economic Alternatives Economic Reform Farmworkers Financialisation Globalization Indonesia Just Transition Labour Process Liberalisation Macroeconomic Policy NUM Nationalism Occupational Health Organising Outsourcing Portugal Privatisation Refugees Regulation Reserve Army of Labour Right to strike Social Dialogue Social Justice Solidarity Tax Evasion Welfare State Workers Rights Workers’ Organisations AMCU Africa Alternative Sources of Power Anti-privatisation Anti-union Violence Automobiles Brazil Business and Human Rights Capital Flight Capitalism Chinese Investment Climate Change Collectivity Colombia Community Monitoring Conference Corporate Transparency Coup Cuba Debt Restructuring Decriminalisation Demand Democracy Developed and Developing Countries Development Digitisation Disciplining of the superfluous labour force Domestic Work Economic Development Egypt Elections Entrepreneurship Eurozone Crisis Executive Compensation Factory Occupations Fair Trade Farm Workers Feminism Finance Financial Crises Financial Innovation Financial crisis. Fiscal Austerity Food Sovereignty G20 Gender Gentrification Global Health Global Multiplier Great Depression Great Recession Hawkers Health Hotel Housekeepers Human Rights due Diligence India Industrial Relations Informal Employment Institutions International Aid Policy International Framework Agreements Investment Partnership (TTIP) Investment Partnerships Iran Korean Shipbuilding Industry Kuznets Labor Labour Broking Labour Income Share Labour Markets Labour Reform Leadership Left Legislation Loi Travail Macroeconomic Performance Management Manufacturing Marshall Plan Metal Workers Migrant Domestic Workers Militarised Capitalism Mineworkers NASVI National Health Service Neolibaralism Networking New Progressive Consensus Online Campaigning Options for the Euro Area Paternalism Patriarchy Pensions Performance Standards Political Alliances Poverty Reduction Precariousness Prison Labour Prisoners Private Plantations Progressive Tax Reform Protectionism Protests Public Policy Quebec Racism Rank-and-File Member Redistribution Regulation of Labour Rent Seeking Rural Development Ruskin SEWA Securitization Sex Work Shadow Banking Shaft Stewards Social Audit Social Development Social Movement Social Transformation Solidarity Economy Spain Sportswear Industry State Stellenbosch Street Trading Street Vendors Strike Ban Strikes Structural Changes Supply Chains Swedish Model Tertiary Education Top Income Shares Tourism Trade Liberalisation Trade Misinvoicing Transatlantic Trade Transformation Transparency Transport Trump Tunsia Turkey Unfree Labour Union 4.0 Union Strategy Unions Universal Health Coverage (UHC) Voluntary Initiatives Wage Employment Wage Inequality Wage Share West Africa Wild Cat Strike Winelands Women Women’s Movement Workers` Organization Youth

    PUBLICATIONS

    Click here to view more

    Blog Archive

    • ►  2020 (1)
      • ►  September (1)
    • ►  2017 (40)
      • ►  December (4)
      • ►  November (2)
      • ►  October (3)
      • ►  September (5)
      • ►  July (4)
      • ►  June (6)
      • ►  May (4)
      • ►  April (3)
      • ►  March (2)
      • ►  February (4)
      • ►  January (3)
    • ►  2016 (34)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (2)
      • ►  October (2)
      • ►  September (4)
      • ►  August (4)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  June (3)
      • ►  May (4)
      • ►  April (1)
      • ►  March (4)
      • ►  February (3)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ►  2015 (32)
      • ►  December (2)
      • ►  November (5)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (2)
      • ►  August (1)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  June (5)
      • ►  May (3)
      • ►  April (2)
      • ►  March (2)
      • ►  February (3)
      • ►  January (1)
    • ►  2014 (32)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (1)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (3)
      • ►  August (1)
      • ►  July (3)
      • ►  June (6)
      • ►  May (2)
      • ►  April (3)
      • ►  March (2)
      • ►  February (2)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ►  2013 (41)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (2)
      • ►  October (5)
      • ►  September (4)
      • ►  August (1)
      • ►  July (4)
      • ►  June (3)
      • ►  May (4)
      • ►  April (3)
      • ►  March (4)
      • ►  February (4)
      • ►  January (4)
    • ▼  2012 (35)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (4)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (2)
      • ►  August (2)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  June (2)
      • ►  May (4)
      • ►  April (3)
      • ►  March (3)
      • ▼  February (4)
        • International Framework Agreements: Possibilities ...
        • The Crisis: the Response of the European Trade Unions
        • A Tide of Inequality: What can Taxes and Transfers...
        • Minimum Wages in Europe: a Strategy against Wage-D...
      • ►  January (2)
    • ►  2011 (39)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (4)
      • ►  October (3)
      • ►  September (4)
      • ►  August (3)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  June (3)
      • ►  May (3)
      • ►  April (4)
      • ►  March (4)
      • ►  February (4)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ►  2010 (39)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (5)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (2)
      • ►  August (2)
      • ►  July (3)
      • ►  June (4)
      • ►  May (1)
      • ►  April (4)
      • ►  March (4)
      • ►  February (4)
      • ►  January (3)
    • ►  2009 (5)
      • ►  December (3)
      • ►  November (2)

     
    Copyright © 2011 Global Labour Column Archive | Powered by Blogger
    Design by Free WordPress Themes | Bloggerized by Lasantha - Premium Blogger Themes | 100 WP Themes